No, cats did not smell your cancer

No, they bloody didn’t. They just didn’t. ‘Cats detected my cancer’, reads a headline on Mail Online. But, let’s face it, they didn’t at all.

The ways in which this story is nonsense are obvious. Stephanie Doody, the woman in question, says (and, I’m sure, believes – and may even be right) that her three cats, whose names are not important but are dutifully reported in the story because of Human Interest, started behaving oddly and prodding her stomach. This, she also says and also no doubt believes (but in this case she is wrong) alerted her to the rare tumour on her appendix, a type which usually goes undetected until it is too late.

Which is all very heartwarming and so on, but look. The cats apparently started acting oddly in February. She didn’t seek medical attention until July. And the story itself says that the reason she went to the GP was not because her cats were prodding her stomach (‘Excuse me, doctor, but Tiddles just slapped me on the abdomen and I was wondering if that means I have cancer’) but because she’d ‘found a small lump after losing some weight’. So, less to do with mystic cancer-smelling cats and more to do with, you know, having symptoms.

The ‘my cat/dog/guinea pig/alpaca smelled my cancer’ trope is well-established, but it is, as far as I can see, codswallop. There is some very slight evidence that trained dogs, in controlled conditions, can detect a difference between the urine of patients with cancer from those without. But it’s far from clear that the dogs are smelling cancer-specific chemicals, rather than odours given off by ill health in general.

And those are trained dogs. The idea that a bog-standard house cat will hoist up its nose and say ‘ooh, that smells a bit cancery to me’ is ludicrous. The far more plausible explanation is that, if the cats really did change behaviour at all, it was for a more prosaic reason (Mrs Doody changed her perfume, or the cats just changed their behaviour because they’re cats), and then, after the fact, Mrs Doody assigned that change in her memory to the cancer, because we always look for meaning and pattern in everything even when it’s not there.

Maybe this doesn’t matter, but I think it does. For a start, it raises the possibility of GP surgeries being flooded by people who are perfectly healthy but whose cat has recently started headbutting them. Second, it gives false reassurance to other people who aren’t healthy, who might ignore real symptoms if their dog isn’t jumping up and down. And in general, pushing cute but hippy-dippy ideas about health and cancer self-diagnosis into the public consciousness just isn’t a responsible thing to do. It seems a short walk from saying cats can detect cancer to claiming that the laying on of hands can cure it.

In short: if your cats start behaving oddly, don’t go to the doctors, you’ll only get laughed at. If, on the other hand, you lose some weight and find a lump, do, whatever your cats are doing. And ignore stories about cats smelling cancer, for god’s sake.

  • Nope

    I’m a skeptical person by nature and try to approach things analytically. I find cases (mostly gastrointestinal cancers) such as these to be plausible simply because of 3 factors:

    1. Sense of smell. Cats and dogs have a much stronger sense of smell by many many magnitudes. They have, in controlled cases, removed all detectable scent by modern measures, i.e. scentless bath, scentproof suits, special breathing apparatuses, etc and dogs can still locate where the “unscented” person is. Even with humans knowingly trying to confuse the animal.

    2. Related to what I said above….let’s not mince around the words….poop and vomit. Dogs and cats identify illness, among other things, in one another by all sorts of bodily excretions. This is most notable in their poop and bile. They can tell where the animal has been, if they’re ovulating, their mood, medical conditions, age, sex, etc.

    3. Domestication. This ties my hypothesis together. We have lived besides cats and dogs in our residences for thousands of years. Many common pets (mainly cats and dogs) have a great sense of smell (see 1.). With said sense of smell, they have evolved to learn information about their kin via scent (see 2.). So isn’t it plausible that in 10 thousand years they have learned to smell some of our conditions as well? After all, cats and dogs can and have shown empathy and sympathy for their owners as well as one another. This has been observed in laboratory studies. They can detect their own illnesses due to secretions in excrement and humans have detectable levels of “foreign” chemicals in some excretions.

    While I do find the likelyhood of all of these cases legitimacy is questionable, I definitely acknowledge the possibility of some truth to it. Just my two cents.

  • Bruno Marcotulli

    But the TRUTH is…the author of that doubting article above has no idea whether cats can smell cancer or not. How could he…he’s not a cat. His dismissal of the concept is simply baseless arrogance…a shot in the dark stated with authority.

    • Oxana

      Agree, the author have some personal issues with felines, probably related to issues with women, sexual. There is a connection between men disliking cats and disrespecting women, based on pretty valid research. It’s definitely strange to have issues with certain animal specie, to the point where you would write public articles, in attempt to derogate the specie even more, and then even drag religion (God) into it.

  • Dana

    You could be right. But there are too many coincidences out there between feline behavioral changes and illness and/or death in whichever person or critter they’re acting oddly about. And your statement that this just plain isn’t happening, with no evidence to back up your assertion, isn’t any more scientific than someone claiming a cat can smell a tumor with no supporting evidence. And what’s the difference, really, between smelling different because you have a tumor and smelling different because you’re in ill health? A benign tumor’s one thing, but by definition if you have a malignant tumor you’re NOT in good health. What a silly argument.

  • PlacidAir

    Your “logic” is what is “codswallop”….. if that didn’t send her to the doctor, that means the cat didn’t sense the cancer? That makes it about what she knew, not what the cat sensed. I have breast cancer. One of my cats kept smacking my in an area that did not show on mammogram, but that turned out to be a mesh of microtumors only found because after cancer was found in a different area, I chose a mastectomy over lumpectomy. What was there was low metabolism and a series of tumors too small to show on scans….. didn’t show on mammogram, sonogram, nor PET scan….. but when they got in there, the area was full of cancer….. right where one of my cats kept smacking me.

    Believe anything you want, but your notion that because the cat behaving that way isn’t how it got found means the cat didn’t sense it is not logical….. the cat wasn’t capable of making the medical appointment.

    • Oxana

      So this guy Tom Chivers, just presents his unjustified opinions as an ultimate and final TRUTH, and is even forbidding readers from believing all other articles and any and all [future]research on this topic , for “god’s sake”? And yet he has no reference, no research behind, no profesional expertise in the field, no education. How ridiculous! Who does he think he is? A psychic? Deity? OMG 😀

  • Roslyn Renwick

    I’m sure different illnesses cause different body smells. We all know, or have been told, that the breath of someone with diabetes smells like pear drops, so why not other illnesses causing other smells? I discovered I could smell colds coming on in people, well before they noticed any symptons. After that, I noticed other illnesses had distinctive smells.

  • Oxana

    My cat did “detected” my cancer in breast. One day out of the blue she started smelling my left side of the right breast like crazy. And kept doing it. Day after day. She was so persistent, I got suspicious. So I went to have it checked. It was stage I exactly at the location. I got it fixed with surgery… There are other stories too. See Cat Detects Owner’s Breast Cancer Before Doctors, Saving Her Life. I think that you are either biased, or not an expert enough to be answering questions like these. You know a little, but not all. For god’s sake, do a comprehensive research before writing articles, keep your personal bias aside, stay objective, and never said never because we don’t fully understand and know about abilities of any animal yet.

  • CanWeTawk

    This article is over 3 years old. So, I will say reading this now is laughable. Obviously the notion of dogs and cats detecting human illnesses was rare, however Mr. Chiver’s article is so arrogant and opinionated. I’m sure now if you looked back at this article he would say oh my gosh, why did I write this? If he’s a real writer / reporter / whatever he claims to be… He should update this article… At least with some backed up research to make his point. But probably that’s why he hasn’t updated this article cuz he can’t prove his side because in three years there’s been an overwhelming amount of pets helping their owners discover that they have some type of ailment. Why would anyone think that they may not have cancer because their dog or cat didn’t detect it is stupid. but if they could help just a little bit and someone discovers that they were sick then it’s a win-win, duh!